The PUK report reveals that big bank regulations, particularly the "too big to fail" (TBTF) legislation, failed to protect Credit Suisse, necessitating state intervention. Despite intentions to bolster resilience and protect taxpayers, exemptions allowed the bank to hide significant equity gaps, leading to a crisis that required a potential nationalization. As reforms are planned, the government must acknowledge the reality of needing to provide substantial rescue funds for systemically important banks in the future.
In December 2022, Ueli Maurer misled the public about the stability of Credit Suisse, despite knowing the bank was in crisis. Following a significant liquidity outflow, he and CS Chairman Axel Lehmann falsely assured the public of a stabilized situation, while internal discussions revealed growing concerns about the bank's viability. By late December, CS's liquidity had drastically diminished, leading to its eventual downfall just months later.
The current Chairman of the Swiss National Bank (SNB), Martin Schlegel, expressed a preference for nationalizing Credit Suisse rather than selling it to UBS, contrasting with the views of his predecessor Thomas Jordan and Finance Minister Karin Keller-Sutter. This disagreement was revealed by a parliamentary commission of inquiry. Schlegel has held the SNB presidency since October 2024.
UBS played a pivotal role in the controversial write-off of $17 billion in Credit Suisse's AT1 bonds during its takeover negotiations, a move that significantly benefited UBS financially. Despite claims of ignorance from UBS Chairman Colm Kelleher, investigations reveal that UBS initiated the discussion on the bond wipe-out, which was crucial for the merger's success. This decision has led to global lawsuits from investors and potential financial repercussions for Swiss taxpayers.
National Bank Chairman Martin Schlegel advocated for the nationalization of Credit Suisse, opposing the takeover by UBS favored by then National Bank Chairman Thomas Jordan and Finance Minister Karin Keller-Sutter. This disagreement was revealed by the Parliamentary Commission of Inquiry.
The Parliamentary Commission of Inquiry revealed a split within the Swiss National Bank (SNB) regarding the Credit Suisse (CS) crisis. While then-Chairman Thomas Jordan and Finance Minister Karin Keller-Sutter favored a UBS takeover, SNB Vice President Martin Schlegel advocated for nationalization, believing it would better ensure financial stability. Additionally, FINMA President Marlene Amstad preferred a restructuring of CS that would keep it under private ownership, but the UBS acquisition ultimately proceeded at a bargain price.
The PUK report reveals significant failings among Swiss authorities in managing the Credit Suisse crisis, highlighting a lack of coordination, mistrust, and delayed action that contributed to the bank's downfall. Despite portraying a successful rescue, the report exposes the inadequacies of FINMA, the SNB, and the Federal Council in crisis management and regulatory oversight. The findings underscore the need for accountability and reform to prevent future banking failures.
A parliamentary commission of inquiry has found that Swiss authorities made significant errors leading to the collapse of Credit Suisse, attributing the loss of trust primarily to the bank's Board of Directors and Executive Board. The investigation revealed that the Financial Market Supervisory Authority (Finma) granted excessive capital relief and failed to act decisively, while the government was criticized for its lack of transparency. In response, the Swiss government plans to reform banking regulations, including stricter capital requirements, and has proposed 30 recommendations to prevent future crises.
The PUK report reveals a troubling relationship between Swiss democracy and major banks, highlighting Ueli Maurer's misleading statements about Credit Suisse's stability before its collapse. The report criticizes the lack of accountability for bank executives and calls for reforms to curb political lobbying and enhance regulatory oversight to prevent future crises.
The ICC report on Credit Suisse has been criticized as uncritical and ineffective, with expert Peter V. Kunz labeling its 20 recommendations as useless. He argues that the report absolves authorities of responsibility, particularly highlighting the failures of the Swiss Financial Market Supervisory Authority (FINMA) while acknowledging the Swiss National Bank's professionalism. Overall, Kunz believes the report wasted valuable time without exerting necessary pressure on policymakers.
Seems like the connection with the server has been lost. It can be due to poor or broken network. Please hang on while we're trying to reconnect...
Oh snap! Failed to reconnect with the server. This is typically caused by a longer network outage, or if the server has been taken down. You can try to reconnect, but if that does not work, you need to reload the page.
Oh man! The server rejected the attempt to reconnect. The only option now is to reload the page, but be prepared that it won't work, since this is typically caused by a failure on the server.
